The Challenge
Multi-Channel Performance Question
Bikaji needed to understand how their celebrity-led ad would perform across different media channels before committing to a large media buy. With Pankaj Tripathi as the face of the campaign, they wanted to maximize the celebrity investment by optimizing placement and creative elements.
The brand was planning significant media spend across YouTube, Facebook, OTT platforms, Instagram Reels, and TV, but needed data-driven insights on which channels would deliver the best ROI and what creative optimizations were necessary.
What Vidopix Discovered
Emotional Journey Analysis
Vidopix's frame-by-frame emotion detection revealed a predominantly neutral emotional tone (78%) throughout the ad. While this isn't necessarily negative, it indicated the ad wasn't creating strong emotional peaks that typically drive memorability and action.
Neutral → High Energy
Pitch sets context but lacks immediate hook
Sad/Frustration Spikes
Repeated "What's the matter?" line creates confusion rather than intrigue
Happy Lift
Smile and location reveal (Lucknow) provide brief positive moment
Mixed/Neutral Close
Weak resolution and missing clear CTA hurt conversion intent
Critical Insights
Celebrity Affinity Present
Strong recognition of Pankaj Tripathi boosted trust and top-of-funnel awareness
Cultural Resonance
Lucknow reference and social sharing cues created local connection (Popularity score: 8/10)
Narrative Confusion
Repetitive "What's the matter?" dialogue diluted core message and caused mid-section drop-off
No Clear CTA
Missing explicit call-to-action hurt conversion intent (CTA Effectiveness: 1/10)
Strengths Identified:
- Celebrity presence drives initial engagement and trust
- Cultural cues (Lucknow location) encourage social sharing
- Taste and quality messaging resonates with target audience
- "Amitji loves Bikaji" line provides strong popularity signal
Critical Gaps Requiring Optimization:
- Repetitive dialogue creates confusion and reduces persuasion
- Quality concerns raised ("It's not working") undermine trust
- No explicit product benefit or unique selling proposition stated
- Missing clear call-to-action ("Try Bikaji today")
- Weak narrative pacing causes mid-section engagement drop
Channel-Specific Recommendations
Recommended Media Placement Strategy
🏆 Primary Channel: YouTube (High Fit)
Longer view-through tolerance and story-building format make YouTube ideal for this 61-second narrative. Viewers are more patient with celebrity-led content.
✅ Secondary Channels: Facebook & OTT (Medium Fit)
Alternative platforms where brand film context helps, but require tighter opening and visible captions for muted autoplay environments.
⚠️ Caution: Instagram Reels (Low-Medium Fit)
Fast-scroll behavior and repetitive pacing create drop-off risk. Requires rapid hook in first 2 seconds.
📺 Consider with Edits: TV 10-15s Cutdowns (Medium Fit)
Could work if re-edited with clear benefit messaging and strong CTA. Current version too long without optimization.
Creative Optimization Checklist
Priority Fixes Before Media Buy:
- Clarify Narrative: Reduce "What's the matter?" repetition loops
- State USP Explicitly: Add taste/quality freshness proof points
- Add Strong CTA: Include "Try Bikaji today" with pack shot in final 5 seconds
- Tighten Pacing: Create punchy edit with memorable end line
- Visual Appetite Cues: Add close-ups, crunch sounds, and smiling faces
Expected Impact
"Brand affinity film featuring celebrity is strong for awareness if clarity improves. Risk: Confusion from repetitive lines reduces persuasion and intent. Action: Re-cut with early brand + benefit cue, add CTA, and validate with A/B testing on YouTube and Facebook."
Projected Outcomes with Optimization:
How This Analysis Was Done
Vidopix analyzed the complete 61-second ad using AI-powered emotion detection across 27 emotions, tracking viewer sentiment frame-by-frame. The platform identified dialogue tone shifts, energy levels, and emotional peaks that correlate with engagement and drop-off patterns.
The analysis included:
- Frame-by-frame emotion mapping (94% accuracy)
- True value signal extraction from dialogue
- Channel fit analysis based on creative format and pacing
- Strengths vs. gaps identification for optimization
- CMO-ready actionable recommendations
Analysis completed in 3 minutes. Traditional focus group testing for this level of insight would take 8-10 hours and cost $5,000-$8,000.
Test Your Ads Before You Spend
Get frame-by-frame insights, channel recommendations, and creative optimization suggestions in minutes—not weeks.
Start Testing Now View More Case Studies